‘Heartbroken’
For the first time in many a month I find myself reading Creative Review.
In it there is an article on one of my favourite subjects: movie posters.
Apparently there is a niche strand of movie poster design that is commissioned for festivals and art house cinemas. The posters are really excellent, but they never see the side of a bus or the wall of your local Cineplex.
In other words, they are the ‘chip shop’ part of that particular discipline.
But the resemblance to advertising doesn’t end there. Under the subhead ‘heartbroken’, the brilliant Corey Holms explains his feelings on trying to get a big client to buy good work:
‘Every poster is a compromise, and I think that a lot of designers have the same feelings that I do, which is that when you look back at your work, all you see is what could have been…the typeface that got changed, or the shot of the star smiling that I was required to use that removed the intended tension in the poster. The most difficult part of the movie poster industry is that 99% of what we do is thrown in the trashcan. We generate a phenomenal amount of work – six to ten unique posters per designer, per round, and you rarely have more than three or four days to complete them. For me, the most frustrating thing is the incredibly difficult balance between caring and not caring. If you care too much then every single revision and comp that dies rips your heart out, so you have to be detached from the work. And if you don’t care enough, your work suffers. Part of the reason I left the industry is because I genuinely care about the work I do and there’s so much amazing work generated that never sees the light of day. I can only have my heart broken so many times.’
Bless.
If you’ve worked in advertising for more than a year, I’m sure that sounds very familiar.
Nice/depressing to know we’re not alone…
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tfDCNpaPBiA
I really wanted to buy those Star Wars prints. Fuckers sold out in like 3 seconds and were going for ten times the value on eBay in 3 minutes.
Hi Ben,
Not sure if there are many independent cinemas by where you live, but they usually choose the more “creative” posters that are available – for example, my current local, the Tyneside Cinema, has all the amazing Black Swan posters you’ve put up and many more. It’s one of the many reasons why they are a more pleasurable place to watch films at, plus many of them allow you to take your pint into the actual theatre.
Guy.
There are a few, but I rarely get a chance to go to the cinema.
Kids, eh?
To be fair the Black Swan poster they ran with was brilliant:
http://www.filmofilia.com/2010/12/08/black-swan-poster-with-natalie-portman/
Agreed.
ben the timing couldn’t be more perfect, was having a frustrating time yesterday at work. When what i though was a good idea, was ‘tweaked’ to suit the client.
that was thrice in as many days.
If you like those Star Wars posters check out these. This guy does posters for bands and has some really nice stuff. I got a book of his prints in Waterstones a couple of weeks ago
http://www.thesmallstakes.com/gallery.php?page=1
Corey old boy, if what Sergethew says is right, then you don’t need to answer to any clients any more. Set up a site and flog your wares. You are the client.
Hardly chip shop. These posters run.
MAybe you should have used D&AD.
Chip shop ads run too.
No Ben, no they don’t.
If you liked the Starwars posters then this site is worth a visit: http://www.geek-art.net/
Constantly amazed by the quality of work.
These movie posters run properly. Surely not chip shop.
Campaign poster awards used to say that anything with less than a ¬£40k media spend was ‘chip shop’. That excluded most work from outside London as there were smaller budgets.
You can have a decent presence in one city on ¬£39k. Does that mean the ads are less valid? They’re done for proper clients with proper money within real campaigns.
Anyway I’m moaning. Obviously a chip shop on my shoulder.
OK, but they’re supposed to. Every award scheme in the world insists that ads actually run. If people can get round that, then shit happens, but lots of dodgy ads for non-clients do actually run somewhere.
That geek art site has some of the worst things I’ve ever seen in my life on it.
I don’t get out much.