Privacy in the face of inconvenience

The other day I was having a chat with some friends who had come round for dinner.

They told me about their forthcoming trip to a resort area in Mexico. We discussed it for a bit then moved on to other things.

The next day I started to receive online ads for that part of Mexico.

We hadn’t emailed about it, hadn’t searched for it (I don’t use Google anyway. The search site I do use, Duck Duck Go, isn’t supposed to pass your search information on to any third parties) and hadn’t made a call about it (not that companies listening in on your calls is OK).

I then tweeted about it and got a surprisingly large response, including some advice and a link to an article that seemed to think it was more down to some kind of coincidence or a second-hand reading of my friends’ emails that then connected to me (even though my friends and I communicate via text; of course those communications could be available to someone nefarious).

The digital community is spying on literally every single thing we do (for advertising purposes, lest we forget). And yes, you were probably aware of such a thing, but were you aware of how utterly brazen the whole situation is? This link shows a video where they boast in a very cosy way about a level of spying that would make a KGB agent blush.

So far so creepy, but what amazes me is the level of complicity that comes from almost all of us. If a man came up to you in the street and told you he had details on every website you’ve ever visited, everything you’ve ever bought, what you earn, your sexual preferences, what your boss thinks of you, your medical history, where you’ve been at any time of the day or night and who you were with, you’d probably find it deeply disturbing. But that’s 100% the case, and it’s not just one man, it’s lots and lots of organisations, many of whom are susceptible to hacking from many more, some of whom might not have your best interests at heart.

And people are now choosing to have Alexas and Echos placed in their homes even thought they’re clearly going to listen to every single thing they say and report back to Amazon and Google (and whoever can hack Amazon and Google), and the government of any country (they can definitely hack Amazon and Google).

I feel as if I’m writing some kind of tin foil hat screed about conspiracy theories, but this is all entirely real, verifiable and not even hidden.

IT IS HAPPENING.

I think perhaps the reason why nothing much is being done about it comes down to three things:

  1. ‘I’ve got nothing to hide so why should I care?’. Fine. Send me an email about everything you think of during sex. I’ll stick it up on the blog then tweet out the link to 5000 people.
  2. ‘I can’t really stop using the internet, can I?’. Fair enough. Everything runs through the internet these days, so detaching from it in any way would be a massive arse. And you have now admitted that convenience is more important to you than the small chance that your (supposedly anonymised) information gets used in a way that can harm you. That makes sense, but it still seems like a massive violation of something we held dear relatively recently.
  3. ‘I had no idea this was happening, at least to this extent.’ I think this category applies to over 90% of internet users and neatly proves the truism that ignorance is bliss. The internet companies don’t want you to know about this and you don’t really want to know either. It’s kind of like putting your hand up the U-bend of a toilet: you know something bad is up there and you won’t get much out of finding out what it is, so it’s best to just not think about it, eh?

So keep talking about your rectal prolapse in front of Siri, using Google to search for that exotic Tumblr site you’d never tell your spouse about, and sharing your entire life with Facebook. It’s just easier that way, isn’t it? And who really wants to leave Instagram just because it’s a thinly-veiled information aggregator for the purposes of advertising, disguised as a picture sharing site? Hardly anyone, apparently.

And I get it: I’m on Instagram, slightly on Facebook (I deleted my account recently but returned in a half-arsed manner to stay in touch with people whose email addresses I didn’t have) and fully engaged on the rest of the internet. But I can’t help wondering how this trade-off slipped so easily into billions of lives.

I also can’t help wondering if a grim and pointy reckoning is on the way. Will we regret selling so much of ourselves for so little?

Edgar Allan Poe said, ‘“It is by no means an irrational fancy that, in a future existence, we shall look upon what we think our present existence, as a dream.”

Dreams come in many shapes and sizes…



ITIAPTWC Episode 48 – Cam Blackley

Here’s my chat with my old AD, Cam Blackley.

Looking at his awards haul since we worked together, you could make a good case for the fact that I was just holding him back: D&AD Gold and Silvers, Titanium and Gold Lions etc., along with a rocket-like career trajectory that has seen him go from AD to CD to ECD to CCO.

Thankfully I’m not in the least bit put out by this, because Cam is such a good bloke.

Check out his many excellent ads, along with our chat, which touches on the following…

Good old laziness leads to advertising.

Grey.

Find the best people and places to work for.

London (another Grey).

AMV!

Working with me.

The ‘benefits’ of redundancy.

Paul and Nigel.

Publicis.

Dave Droga.

NY.

Million.

Sydney.

CDing.

ECD@BMF.

‘Do you really want to make that?’

M&C CCO.

‘Be careful of long term dreams.’

Here’s our chat, the iTunes link and the Soundcloud link, along with some of the ads he and I did together:

 

If This Is A Blog Then What's Christmas?
If This Is A Blog Then What's Christmas?
ITIAPTWC Episode 48 - Cam Blackley
Loading
/


Say your prayers, little one. Don’t forget, my son, to include the weekend.

People having a shit day.

Soderbergh.

Weird music.

The truth behind the scenes of photos.

This never gets old:



Once there was a way To get back homeward. Once there was a way to get back home. Sleep, pretty darling, do not cry! And I will sing the weekend.

Amusing photos of stupid stuff.

Robert Plant’s musical life.

Stupidest doctor/patient stories.

Visions of T:

Advertising we should all aspire to:

Nice film:



Going on a living spree, plenty wanna come with me. You don’t wanna miss your chance, near-life experience. Faces making the weekend.

For fans of The Deuce: when Times Square was gritty.

The utterly fascinating Race of Life (thanks, J):

Amusing design fails.

The amazing soup robot.

The bird:

Sleeping people embroidered onto handmade pillows (thanks, N).



ITIAPTWC Episode 47 – Hugh Todd

Like most episodes of ITIAPTWC, my chat with Hugh offers many thought-provoking lessons on creating work, doing your best for different bosses and working out what to do next.

In addition, Hugh started around the same time I did, so I found the parallels and separations between his career and mine an interesting lesson in how you can choose many different paths in this business.

So we discuss that, and…

Watford.

Journalism.

Teaming up with Adam.

Trudging round Soho.

Making Harley Davidson.

BBH.

Euro 96.

Good brief/tough brief.

Gail Porter.

Hegarty.

Saatchis/Droga (he made shit happen).

Coco De Mer.

Toyota radio ad from real life.

Tony Granger to Nick Bell.

JWT.

Golden Skins. 30 albinos.

Post-Nick (Russell).

Post-Adam.

Lonely-o Burnetts, then a new team.

Co-op.

Back to Saatchis (and HSBC).

Then VCCP.

Man Shitty.

(Slight) return to journalism.

This is Hugh’s site, which contains all the work we discuss, along with his writing. And this is his blog.

Here’s our chat, the iTunes link and the Soundcloud link, along with a special topical link I think Hugh will enjoy:

 

If This Is A Blog Then What's Christmas?
If This Is A Blog Then What's Christmas?
ITIAPTWC Episode 47 – Hugh Todd
Loading
/


You gotta speed it up and then you gotta slow it down. ‘Cause if you believe that a love can hit the top you gotta play the weekend.

Brand logos as weapons.

The gay architects of classic rock.

Great article about Tom McElligot.

The greatest Instagram site on the planet.

Colour palettes of famous movies (thanks, C).

New excellent squatty potty ad (better written than any ad I’ve seen for years):

Ahhhhhh… I’d forgotten how great The Sopranos was:



We got some thin’ we both know it, we don’t talk too much about it. Ain’t no real big secret, all the same, somehow we get around the weekend.

Christoph Nieman’s excellent illustrations.

Best cinematography of the 21st Century.

Different dinnertimes across the USA.

Unintentionally bad movie posters.

Interesting historical photos.

Use stock footage to make a cool movie:

Fluid sculpture:



We’ve done sexism, now let’s have a look at diversity

This ad’s been doing the rounds a bit lately:

Good for Jigsaw.

I can’t argue with anything written there.

But I can’t help wondering, after that thing I wrote about Femvertising, if Jigsaw is projecting at all.

I mean, after all they wrote, they couldn’t possibly have an entirely caucasian management team, could they?

To be entirely fair, I have no idea which of these people (if any) is an immigrant, and maybe the fifteen black, Asian and Inuit people on the management team were unavailable that day, but there does seem to be a lack of racial diversity in that picture.

The tricky thing is there’s very little transparency regarding the racial makeup of Jigsaw’s management. I had a good long trawl through their staff pictures on LinkedIn and they certainly seemed to be predominately white, but there’s no official shots of the people in charge as a group.

So it’s all well and good telling us you stand for immigration and, by extension, racial diversity, but in this day and age we need you to show us the extent to which that is your stance. A racially diverse management team would demonstrate that Jigsaw really means what they say, and it might inspire others to emulate its progressive attitude (if such a thing exists).

It’s one thing to explain how wonderfully committed you are. It’s entirely another to put your hiring policy where your mouth is.



ITIAPTWC Episode 46 – Dave Dye Part 6

Here’s my 6th, and hopefully not final, chat with Dave Dye. It’s the story of DHM and the various occurrences that created the excellent work at the bottom of this post.

As always with Dave, there are many excellent lessons for anyone who is either running or starting an agency, including…

Temporary time with Paul Silburn.

Looking for new partners (trust).

The name: Thingy? Not Thingy. Alphabetical order.

The Publicis breakaway that wasn’t.

‘Commissioning editor’.

New business/’interesting’ first pitch.

Fiddly and not lucrative but fun and good quality bits of business.

Creative Circle/David Abbott/awkward.

‘David Abbott in parts?’

Vertu: the unblingy-blingy phone.

Freelance: expensive quality over cheap quantity.

The Economist.

Jorian’s departure.

Hello Soho Square/Hello People/Goodbye Justin.

The hell of the name thing (‘Thingy’ rejected again).

‘My favourite thing I’ve done’.

A ‘disappointing’ new business ‘funnel’. ‘The very difficult thing is winning business’.

Further chats: digital; the rarity and difficulty of ideas that hold things together; the role of art directors way more important now; what you can say at different ages; has the job really changed?; the skill of distillation; more writing needed today.

It’s best to be cynical.

Here’s the chat, the iTunes link and the Soundcloud link:

And the aforementioned excellent work:

Two ads written by David Abbott:

And that ‘Beano’ Creative Circle Annual page:

 

 

46. ‘Mindmap’ The Economist, DHM 50. Fallon Campaign dps 2 51. Wiedens Campaign dps2 52. Mother Campaign dps.2

 

If This Is A Blog Then What's Christmas?
If This Is A Blog Then What's Christmas?
ITIAPTWC Episode 46 – Dave Dye Part 6
Loading
/